Is this a faithful recreation of the version of Graham’s Hierarchy of Disagreement with 2 additional bottom levels?

  • Digit@lemmy.wtfOP
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    15 hours ago

    Took a while to contemplate how mere contradiction could be fallacious. It could be:

    • semantic strawman.
    • bare assertion fallacy.
    • argument from ignorance fallacy.
    • false dilemma.
    • appeal to emotion.
    • moving goal posts.
    • circular reasoning.
    • non sequitur. (… ghadamn! I spelled that correctly for the first time! (thnx to another lemmy user correcting me last time.))
    • bandwaggon fallacy.
    • red herring.

    But, that was a good point to raise. On face value, it is at first difficult to see how mere contradiction can be fallacious.

    (And I confess, only the first of those I came up with entirely by my self. The others were suggested by an LLM, with examples which I’ve omitted for brevity.)