Nearly one out of every three floors of office space in downtown Denver is available.
At the end of the third quarter, total office vacancy in the cityâs core was 30.6%, according to CBRE.
The real estate services firm said itâs the first time downtown total vacancy has hit 30% âin the post-2000 era.â A spokeswoman provided quarterly figures going back to 2006, which show vacancy was as low as 9.5% in early 2008 and during the Great Recession went only as high as 17.4%.
The rate didnât top 20% until the first quarter of 2021, as the effects of the pandemic set in on the office market. The 30% mark came just two-and-a-half years later.
âTotal vacancyâ includes both âdirect vacancy,â which is space no one uses that a landlord is marketing, in addition to sublease space, which is being marketed by a tenant that wants to vacate. Direct vacancy downtown was 26% at the end of the third quarter.
CBRE broker Allison Berry, who represents downtown landlords, noted itâs not as if something changed overnight. Total vacancy was up 1.3 percentage points from the second quarter and 2 percentage points from the same time last year.
âWeâve kind of been in this position for a few years now,â Berry said.
But 30% âis a psychological number,â said Jim Tyler, a broker with Kentwood Commercial who represents tenants seeking space.
Tyler, 60, said downtown Denver hasnât hit 30% since 1990, shortly after he started working in the research department of what is now CBRE. The energy industry had contracted after a decade that saw multiple new towers like Tabor Center and Republic Plaza built.
âItâs a historic mark,â Tyler said.
CBREâs definition of âdowntownâ includes the Central Business District and LoDo, as well as LoHiâs Platte Street and a portion of Uptown. It doesnât include RiNo, Cherry Creek or other spots farther afield.
Total downtown vacancy was 16.5% at the end of 2019. The rate has been steadily increasing since the onset of the COVID pandemic, which prompted many companies to rethink their use of office space. Other factors like homelessness and crime, as well as increased development in Cherry Creek, are seen as playing a role in downtownâs numbers as well.
A representative of JLL, another massive real estate services firm, confirmed that its own research also shows downtown Denver has hit the 30% mark. A local executive noted that other parts of the metro area are doing better.
âOur suburban markets are notably tighter â 10 percentage points lower, in fact â and resting below suburban vacancies across a good number of cities throughout the US. JLL data indicates an overall vacancy rate of 22.9%, which is in line with the national average among primary markets,â JLL Research Director TJ Jaroszewski said in a statement.
The pandemic has prompted a real estate industry maxim dubbed the âflight to quality,â which states that firms that do want office space want the best possible version of it.
Office buildings are assigned a letter grade meant to correspond to their desirability. Class âAâ buildings are often the newest, offering the most in-demand layouts and amenities. Over time, buildings see their grade naturally decline, although owners often undertake renovations to counteract that.
CBREâs research found that Class B and C office buildings are the drivers behind downtownâs rising vacancy, with those buildings collectively having vacancy of 35.5% at the end of the third quarter, up 2.8 percentage points year over year.
Class A buildings were 23.1% vacant, up just 0.6 percentage points since the same quarter in 2022.
âUnfortunately thereâs winners and losers,â Berry said. âThirty percent is obviously a number we never want to see, but there are some bright spots.â
Berry said the downtown rate is also affected by some buildings being âessentially unable to transact right nowâ due to being in foreclosure or distressed in some other way.
âItâs a drag on the statistics but itâs not a drag on the market because theyâre not really competing for deals,â she said.
Despite the uptick, CBREâs research found that average asking rent for downtown office space has remained relatively constant for the last year. Berry said some landlords are willing to make deals, but theyâre more likely to offer incentives like free rent or covering buildout costs â both generally more exciting to tenants than a lower base rent.
Tyler said, âItâs never been a better time to get concessions.â
âThere are some deals out there, but youâve got to shop to find them ⊠Itâs not every building, and itâs not every corner,â he said.
In the early 1990s, Tyler said, downtown recovered in part because no one built new office space for years, allowing the oversupply to gradually lease up.
This time around, however, some are still breaking ground. A half-dozen smaller office buildings are under construction in Cherry Creek and RiNo. And in April 2022, a Chicago-based developer broke ground on a 30-story, 700,000-square-foot tower downtown.
The law firm Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher has taken the top floor at 1900 Lawrence. But no additional leases have been announced since last November. The tower is not included in downtownâs vacancy figures because itâs not completed; itâs expected to wrap up next year.
Tyler said the 30% figure may understate downtownâs challenges, because some companies signed leases pre-pandemic and now arenât using the space, but arenât bothering to market it for sublease.
âThereâs a lot of what I would call âghost spaceâ â space being paid for and not being occupied, and they havenât made decisions,â he said.
Berry, meanwhile, said sheâs hoping for a quick recovery â but it probably doesnât start just yet.
âI think there might be a little more pain,â she said.
Yes, the American experiment with segregated uses continues to fail. The solutions have existed for millennia.
The sooner we accept this and move on, the sooner our cities can be the vibrant, healthy places they couldâve been a long time ago.