I mean, yeah, anarchism doesnt automatically imply rugged individualism, the most core aspect of all forms of anarchism is the distribution of power and reduction/elimination of unjust hierarchies. Doesn’t mean leadership and structure can’t form. People who are good at organizing and logistics and managing complex systems still have a place in an anarchist society.
Like in Star Trek, the episode Allegiance, the bridge crew continued to follow orders of the body swapped Captain Picard until things felt too… off… and orders became nonsensical then they basically just refused to comply knowing something was wrong. They clearly operated within a heirarchy of command, but as soon as the legitimacy of command came into question, tne bridge crew was ready to act to remove someone questionable from power and its framed as a good thing.
I’ll admit Starfleet clearly has some problems, things like Section 31 existing, and clearly has a badmiral problem (which I think is a structural problem of once you reach the pinnacle of star fleet and become an admiral there is nothing aspirational left to do other than push ethical boundaries.) But this still an example of a just hierarchy and the ability to correct and remove unjust hierarchy.
It implies the absence of hierarchy, so you can’t be subject to any law or instruction you don’t personally agree to. That’s not any kind of democracy, where everyone is subject (up to and including by threat of violence) to the law that the majority vote for.
I don’t know what’s up with people sanewashing anarchism. It’s pretty extreme - you can just not subscribe to it as an ideology!
switzerland already did that to some degree. turns out a whole lot of democracy is boring stuff that most people don’t want to bother with, it’s only some specific decisions they want total control over.
imo the right answer would be a system where elected representatives exist but can lose their power at any time. like, imagine a system where voting power on legislation belongs to the people, and bills get introduced through having the support of a certain number of people, but you can delegate your voting power to a representative of your choice, at any time you want, with no fixed terms.
protests would have teeth in a system like that, because they would directly result in the refusal and re-delegation of power immediately, with no need to wait for elections, and no need to weigh a low number of parties. you can just select whoever to handle your vote, whenever. and if you don’t like that person, select someone else.
we could even include an option to override your rep and directly vote on specific issues without having to change reps or throwing your vote away on the day-to-day technicalities that your rep would understand far better than you.
Til social democracy is anarchism
I mean, yeah, anarchism doesnt automatically imply rugged individualism, the most core aspect of all forms of anarchism is the distribution of power and reduction/elimination of unjust hierarchies. Doesn’t mean leadership and structure can’t form. People who are good at organizing and logistics and managing complex systems still have a place in an anarchist society.
Like in Star Trek, the episode Allegiance, the bridge crew continued to follow orders of the body swapped Captain Picard until things felt too… off… and orders became nonsensical then they basically just refused to comply knowing something was wrong. They clearly operated within a heirarchy of command, but as soon as the legitimacy of command came into question, tne bridge crew was ready to act to remove someone questionable from power and its framed as a good thing.
I’ll admit Starfleet clearly has some problems, things like Section 31 existing, and clearly has a badmiral problem (which I think is a structural problem of once you reach the pinnacle of star fleet and become an admiral there is nothing aspirational left to do other than push ethical boundaries.) But this still an example of a just hierarchy and the ability to correct and remove unjust hierarchy.
It implies the absence of hierarchy, so you can’t be subject to any law or instruction you don’t personally agree to. That’s not any kind of democracy, where everyone is subject (up to and including by threat of violence) to the law that the majority vote for.
I don’t know what’s up with people sanewashing anarchism. It’s pretty extreme - you can just not subscribe to it as an ideology!
if you perhaps replace representative democracy with direct democracy
switzerland already did that to some degree. turns out a whole lot of democracy is boring stuff that most people don’t want to bother with, it’s only some specific decisions they want total control over.
imo the right answer would be a system where elected representatives exist but can lose their power at any time. like, imagine a system where voting power on legislation belongs to the people, and bills get introduced through having the support of a certain number of people, but you can delegate your voting power to a representative of your choice, at any time you want, with no fixed terms.
protests would have teeth in a system like that, because they would directly result in the refusal and re-delegation of power immediately, with no need to wait for elections, and no need to weigh a low number of parties. you can just select whoever to handle your vote, whenever. and if you don’t like that person, select someone else.
we could even include an option to override your rep and directly vote on specific issues without having to change reps or throwing your vote away on the day-to-day technicalities that your rep would understand far better than you.
Sounds like liquid democracy:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_democracy