If there is a non-violent solution to a problem, that should always be preferred and is also IMO the best way in the grand scheme of things. And if there is not, it might be also worth considering if the problem to be solved is actually a problem in the first place. But a few problems are left where violence might be the only solution.
Also “the best” doesn’t mean “the most effective”. Many many problems can be solved pretty effectively with a violent act. Or the violence is the simplest approach. But it wouldn’t be the best.
“effective” is a binary measure; pretty much absolute. “best” typically implies “optimum” or “efficient”, so a trade-off, because a one-sided effect is typically not optimal. And as I said: sometimes the effective solutions is the optimal one. But I think that’s the exception.
What is “this context”? Every situation is different and the range of options depends on the situation.
Is someone talking shit to you? Smashing their teeth in will stop that in the moment; that’s effective. Cutting their tongue out is effective in the long run. Cutting their head off too. It’s not exactly a good solution, since it’s completely out of line and likely ends with you in jail for good reason. A good solution would have been to either ignore them or sue them because those are fitting responses and within the bounds of society we agreed to live in.
I feel like you might be mixing two things here.
If there is a non-violent solution to a problem, that should always be preferred and is also IMO the best way in the grand scheme of things. And if there is not, it might be also worth considering if the problem to be solved is actually a problem in the first place. But a few problems are left where violence might be the only solution.
Also “the best” doesn’t mean “the most effective”. Many many problems can be solved pretty effectively with a violent act. Or the violence is the simplest approach. But it wouldn’t be the best.
Without defining what “the best” and “most effective” mean for you, your entire comment is a bit of a non sequitur.
“effective” is a binary measure; pretty much absolute. “best” typically implies “optimum” or “efficient”, so a trade-off, because a one-sided effect is typically not optimal. And as I said: sometimes the effective solutions is the optimal one. But I think that’s the exception.
Yes, but within this context what is the threshold for effective? What is the metric by which you measure efficiency?
What is “this context”? Every situation is different and the range of options depends on the situation.
Is someone talking shit to you? Smashing their teeth in will stop that in the moment; that’s effective. Cutting their tongue out is effective in the long run. Cutting their head off too. It’s not exactly a good solution, since it’s completely out of line and likely ends with you in jail for good reason. A good solution would have been to either ignore them or sue them because those are fitting responses and within the bounds of society we agreed to live in.
Big if