In some sense, yes. The secure the borders thing a weird and unnecessary addition, but the monopoly on violence thing is pretty spot on. The state has a legal monopoly on violence. But that position is not at all what the OP is arguing against.
Some people would extend the above to a kind of moral monopoly. They see someone employ violent tactics to rebel against the state, and they will say “this is morally wrong”, or “this is not the way to do things”, or “would someone please think of the optics?”. They look at the violence employed by people in the BLM movement and argue against it. They look at the stonewall riots and argue against it. They look at people violently resisting the nazis in the second world war, and they argue against it, from a moral perpective. That is what this post is about.
I mean, statehood only works if you can secure your borders, you cease to be a state if you can’t. It’s just the minimum definition of a state without, I should say, any moral evaluation. There are states I’d be happy to live in and states I won’t visit. They’re still states.
I agree that broadly speaking all power comes from the threat of violence, or as Mao says grows from the barrel of a gun. Peaceful protests can still be threatening, though. We’ve seen many more or less peaceful protests succeed.
My country became a democracy because people marched to the palace and asked nicely. The implicit threat being that next time the mob might not ask nicely.
In some sense, yes. The secure the borders thing a weird and unnecessary addition, but the monopoly on violence thing is pretty spot on. The state has a legal monopoly on violence. But that position is not at all what the OP is arguing against.
Some people would extend the above to a kind of moral monopoly. They see someone employ violent tactics to rebel against the state, and they will say “this is morally wrong”, or “this is not the way to do things”, or “would someone please think of the optics?”. They look at the violence employed by people in the BLM movement and argue against it. They look at the stonewall riots and argue against it. They look at people violently resisting the nazis in the second world war, and they argue against it, from a moral perpective. That is what this post is about.
I mean, statehood only works if you can secure your borders, you cease to be a state if you can’t. It’s just the minimum definition of a state without, I should say, any moral evaluation. There are states I’d be happy to live in and states I won’t visit. They’re still states.
I agree that broadly speaking all power comes from the threat of violence, or as Mao says grows from the barrel of a gun. Peaceful protests can still be threatening, though. We’ve seen many more or less peaceful protests succeed.
My country became a democracy because people marched to the palace and asked nicely. The implicit threat being that next time the mob might not ask nicely.