- Big Tech has implemented passkeys in a way that locks users into their platforms rather than providing universal security
- Passkeys were developed to replace passwords for better account security, but their rollout by Apple and Google has limited their potential
- Proton Pass offers passkeys that are universal, easy to use, and available to everyone for improved online security and privacy.
I’m very excited for the concept of passkeys, but indeed it is a bit of a mess right now. Android password managers can’t use passkey inside other apps, basically limited to just the browser. I hope it all gets sorted soon and everyone sticks to an open standard compatibility.
I want to be able to export my passkeys and take them with me to any other chosen passkey manager.
I have hopes for a normal implementation because KeepassXC does have passkeys now.
The idea of a passkey is that it is a security certificate that permanently bound to the software/hardware and can’t be exfiltrated, in the same fashion you’d make one SSH private key per device connecting to a server, never leaving the computer it was generated from. Or how you’d keep your primary PGP keys in a safe location and deploy a unique subkey per device to use it. That way you can revoke an individual subkey if compromised, without revoking the entire chain.
You don’t backup your Passkeys, you associate multiple passkeys per account (ie: ProtonPass, Bitwarden, Yubikeys) as a contingency.
If you can back it up, it can be stolen.
Hmmm see this is how I thought it worked but then Google and Apple providers are syncing passkeys around devices without issue? There are definitely backups and cloud syncs happening. I’m aiming to use an OS agnostic provider like 1password which I’d expect to sync across hardware- but with everything in its infancy I’m not sure how that shakes out.
But tbh that does bring up another concern of mine: I have some 200+ accounts, assuming a passkey world where everything is using them, if a user wanted to change ecosystems it seems they will need to visit every service, edit the account and reconfigure their keys instead of transferring the private keys into the new ecosystem? Sounds like a nightmare!
they are syncing, but under no circumstances it let you see the passkey’s private key in a format that you can import elsewhere, which reduce the amount of damage that can be done, but still if an attacker gain access to your Google account and its “password manager” (or any other password managers tbh) it’s mostly game over at that point.
Personally I don’t have all my passkeys on a physical device, they’re mostly stored in my Bitwarden vault for the convenience of multi-device sync, and the important accounts that offers SSO into other services (Google, Facebook, Amazon, Apple, plus Bitwarden) are protected by multiple hardware tokens with a Passkey for redundancies.
Security is as strong as its weakest link.
For the accounts that are highly important, you might want to use only keys that are bound to a device like a computer, phone, or hardware security key. This would require a bit of manual management as you swap out devices and hardware keys but for a limited number of important accounts this should be feasible. For all the other general accounts, storing them in a password manager can continue to be the most convenient way to use them. The Google/Apple/Microsoft solutions take this second approach and allow them to be synced across devices.
As for the portability, it’s still relatively early and I don’t think there’s a standardized format to export passkeys into. It’s only a matter of time before things settle down and different password/passkey managers support importing and exporting to at least one format that will work.
Same; I hope the EU does something before it’s a total mess