I love the Dark Tower books but totally agree that the latter 4 are definitely weaker. I think it is worth a read despite the time commitment but it definitely slowly gets worse towards the end with a bit of a Meh ending. My second turn of the wheel was definitely better in terms of the ending though.
Also the majority of that list you’ve written there are fucking great books.
Insomnia I thought was a bit over rated but not really bad.
Hearts in Atlantis and Doctor Sleep were eh.
And Fairy Tale wasnt bad but also j don’t think worth the time.
I was originally disappointed by the ending as well. But the more I thought about it, the more I came the conclusion that it’s the only ending that works. Anything more… definite would’ve been a much bigger letdown, I’m sure.
And besides… he now has the Horn!
I do agree. I still think the last few books aren’t as strong as the first 4 which are fucking awesome but like you say the more I thought about it the more I like it.
It has been a couple of years and I think I will go through all the books again sometime within the next year and I am confident that my third go around will be even better again. I would genuinely enjoy reading how the horn would change things!
I think I can definitively say why the others are weaker too…
In the first four books, you have flashbacks to the young Roland and his friends, it’s not a straight narrative. Book 4 is virtually all flashback, but you do have the “present day” narrative resolving the cliffhanger from book 3, and other bits with Jake, Eddie and Susan.
Starting with book 5, there are no flashbacks and barely any mention of previous times. It’s like King used the flashbacks in 1-3 to foreshadow book 4, worked it all out of his system, and went “Welp, done with that now!”
5-7 are all straight narrative with nothing to break them up and I think they’re lesser for it.
You have ALL these hints about the Young Roland and his friends and what happened at Jericho Hill and no payoff for any of it. I had figured that the final book would also have the Jericho Hill story and… nothing.
There was a comic book version, but that was written by someone else. I know, I know, King “approved” it, but it’s not the same thing. :(
I love the Dark Tower books but totally agree that the latter 4 are definitely weaker. I think it is worth a read despite the time commitment but it definitely slowly gets worse towards the end with a bit of a Meh ending. My second turn of the wheel was definitely better in terms of the ending though.
Also the majority of that list you’ve written there are fucking great books.
Insomnia I thought was a bit over rated but not really bad.
Hearts in Atlantis and Doctor Sleep were eh.
And Fairy Tale wasnt bad but also j don’t think worth the time.
I read Hearts in Atlantis for what amounted to 2 pages. Hehe.
I was originally disappointed by the ending as well. But the more I thought about it, the more I came the conclusion that it’s the only ending that works. Anything more… definite would’ve been a much bigger letdown, I’m sure. And besides… he now has the Horn!
I do agree. I still think the last few books aren’t as strong as the first 4 which are fucking awesome but like you say the more I thought about it the more I like it.
It has been a couple of years and I think I will go through all the books again sometime within the next year and I am confident that my third go around will be even better again. I would genuinely enjoy reading how the horn would change things!
I think I can definitively say why the others are weaker too…
In the first four books, you have flashbacks to the young Roland and his friends, it’s not a straight narrative. Book 4 is virtually all flashback, but you do have the “present day” narrative resolving the cliffhanger from book 3, and other bits with Jake, Eddie and Susan.
Starting with book 5, there are no flashbacks and barely any mention of previous times. It’s like King used the flashbacks in 1-3 to foreshadow book 4, worked it all out of his system, and went “Welp, done with that now!”
5-7 are all straight narrative with nothing to break them up and I think they’re lesser for it.
You have ALL these hints about the Young Roland and his friends and what happened at Jericho Hill and no payoff for any of it. I had figured that the final book would also have the Jericho Hill story and… nothing.
There was a comic book version, but that was written by someone else. I know, I know, King “approved” it, but it’s not the same thing. :(
I heard there was a comic book but I hadn’t checked it out, do you not think it is worth it?
I too also always wondered what happened at Jericho Hill.
Marvel did a BUNCH of Dark Tower comics, some adaptations, some original like Jericho Hill.
The art is amazing, but the original stuff is not King.