Hello folks,

Recently moved to a new flat and have been rethinking my networking stack. Current stack is a full tp-link omada setup:

  • Router: ER605
  • Switch: 8-port TL-SG2008P
  • Controller: OC200
  • First AP: EAP610 Wifi
  • Second AP: EAP615-Wall Wifi 6

While this has been functional and reliable, i cannot stand the UI, its slow and sluggish and overall hasn’t been a great experience to configure. Therefore i am now looking to swap this out with something new.

My inital thought was to swap this out with the equivalent Unifi gear. However, OPNsense was recently updated and has never looked juicier. Im torn between the these two choices and unsure what hardware to go for. Unifi is tempting as it looks amazing and is easy to configure. OPNsense is tempting as it is open-source, not enterprise thus less prone to enshitification, and likely to be cheaper too.

My use case is: 2 people, 10 devices ish in total, for a flat of 85 square meteres. Got a few different serveres, two desktops, 3 phones, tv, laptops etc. Servers, deskrops and tv will go wired, rest is wireless.

I am by no means a professional, but not a total noob either. Looking to set up wireguard tunnel, vlans for different devices and guest network.

I would love some input on this to would weigh in on my final desicion. What are you running, are you hapoy with it, are you looking to change, etc…

Thanks in advance for any tips or recommendations!

  • irq0@infosec.pubEnglish
    2·
    13 hours ago

    I used to run PFSense ( pretty much the same as Opensense ) and really liked it but moved over to Ubiquity in the last year or so. Here’s my 2 cents…

    Go with Ubiquity if you want a single unified interface for managing all your devices. You’ll have “soft vendor lock in”, their kit will work just fine with a mix of hardware but it’s best if everything is Ubiquity

    Go with Opensense if you want complete flexibility in the kit you’re using. I feel likeI had more fine grained control with PFSense than I do with Ubiquity but I think that’s a symptom of how the UI/UX rather than the features

    You can do the same stuff with both options. I’m very happy with my Ubiquity set up, I don’t see myself changing anything anytime soon