One of these days I’m gonna have to read the whole thing myself, but in the first few pages the ST:TMP novelization, Roddenberry himself sort of implies that Starfleet is full of deeply conservative throwbacks who have a weird combination of wanderlust and tolerance for authority that life on post-scarcity Earth cannot satisfy, and that both they and the Earthbound population are happier with Starfleet personnel being off-planet.
It strikes me as a hand-wavey way to justify to himself how he can have a free-love, no-money utopian society, yet all the media he could manage to get made is basically showing us a combination of NASA and the US Navy, with a pretty marked tendency towards the latter. For Gene, any 23rd-century people whom 20th-century minds could even comprehend would have to be psychological Luddites.
One of these days I’m gonna have to read the whole thing myself, but in the first few pages the ST:TMP novelization, Roddenberry himself sort of implies that Starfleet is full of deeply conservative throwbacks who have a weird combination of wanderlust and tolerance for authority that life on post-scarcity Earth cannot satisfy, and that both they and the Earthbound population are happier with Starfleet personnel being off-planet.
It strikes me as a hand-wavey way to justify to himself how he can have a free-love, no-money utopian society, yet all the media he could manage to get made is basically showing us a combination of NASA and the US Navy, with a pretty marked tendency towards the latter. For Gene, any 23rd-century people whom 20th-century minds could even comprehend would have to be psychological Luddites.