Right, so the parking lot covered with shredded dictionaries needs a human mind or else its just a bunch of trash.
The human inside the Chinese room, or in the parking lot picking up and organizing the trash, or in a discussion with a chatbot is still critical to the overall intelligence/knowledgeability of the system. It’s still needed for that spark and, without it, it’s just trash.
Right, so the parking lot covered with shredded dictionaries needs a human mind or else its just a bunch of trash.
The human inside the Chinese room, or in the parking lot picking up and organizing the trash, or in a discussion with a chatbot is still critical to the overall intelligence/knowledgeability of the system. It’s still needed for that spark and, without it, it’s just trash.