• finallymadeanaccount@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    Alternatively, could they not have just had a bunch of enthusiastic people with hammers and chisels going to town on the rock around the cave? 50/60 people could make short work of it, assuming the vibrations didn’t cause a cave in.

    • tal@lemmy.today
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      12
      ·
      edit-2
      2 days ago

      I watched a video a while back from one of the rescuers who used a video game that VR-simulates the cave to demonstrate the situation.

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Tyk1DUqlvI

      It really illustrates how little space they had to work with. You could get one person with very little space to work with or maneuver tools near the victim.

      The victim was upside down and surrounded by rock.

      The guy says that they tried a jackhammer, and it took them IIRC hours to get through about two inches.

      EDIT: The victim also died from cardiac arrest from being in that position before too long:

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nutty_Putty_Cave

      After around 27 hours of being stuck and extensive rescue efforts, Jones was pronounced dead at 11:56 pm on November 25.[8][9]

      A medic verified that Jones had ultimately suffered cardiac arrest and died due to the strain placed upon his body over many hours by his inverted, compressed position.

      That places some hard time constraints on them.

      I don’t really know how they could have cleared out that much rock that quickly with the limited access and without doing anything that would kill the victim more quickly.

      EDIT2: Also, based on the video I linked, the jackhammering that they were trying wasn’t even right at the victim, but a couple turns back up the cave, so I don’t even know for sure if they could fit the jackhammer down the shaft as far as he’d gone.

      And I just read the report that someone else linked in this thread, and it said that when they reached him, he had retrograde amnesia. They also said that none of the rescuers who were as large as the victim could reach as far down the cave as the victim, so given those two data points, they think that he might have fallen, hit his head, and then slid down further, and it was the force of the fall that maybe helped force him past a tight spot.

      If they got him up, he’d have to be going backwards, and they’d be fighting gravity to bring him up rather than benefitting from the fall that sent him down.

      It also mentioned that one rescuer got stuck going down to help the victim and got out because he’d attached webbing to his legs before going in and other rescuers were able to use that to haul him out.

      Just provides some perspective on how difficult the problem they were facing was.

      • tal@lemmy.today
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        6
        ·
        3 days ago

        Honestly, I’m not sure that it would have been practical to have jackhammered the guy out even if the time constraints were relaxed. Like, I assume that they were putting some amount of dust into the air and rubble into the cavity. At some point, the guy isn’t going to be able to breathe under that. Maybe if you could squeeze some kind of shop-vac hose down by his head or something, and if he stayed conscious and could tell you where it was to help you operate it…