@youshouldknow YSK that you can post to Lemmy from Mastodon, and Mastodon users can interact in Lemmy threads. This is a Mastodon account.
Seems like there’s a new wave of Lemmy users, thought they may find that interesting! It can also work with other Fediverse software as well. It’s all interconnectable. It’s not perfect and there’s some quirks due to Lemmy being a forum and Mastodon being a microblog. But you can ping Mastodon users in threads, and they can reply seamlessly.
But can you post from lemmy to Mastodon?
I’m not asking if it would make sense, I just feel left out cause of the one sided posting ability
Ok, so Mastodon can post to lemmy, does this also work the other way around? And could I follow persons on mastodon somehow woth my Lemmy account? Does this show up as a small community?
I think the way Lemmy / PieFed are set up you can’t inherently “follow” someone like a feed. PieFed being an article posting site (?) Like Lemmy they support each other right away. So posts on that platform while written in another programming language, still mesh and show.
No. Lemmy doesn’t support following people. Best you can do is mention them and they’ll get your ping. Or DM them.
Example response from PieFed
I’ve tried explaining the fed to my friends and family like “it’s like insta and FB and xitter and reddit all got to talk to one another and there’s different organizations like email has”. I’m not sure they get it much better.
I just explain but starting how you can email gmail from Outlook and such ( familiar concept). Then tell them you could email a Facebook account using
username@facebook.com(this shows they were open to it at some point), that it was a default state of things because they wanted you connected. But then they realized they can make you sign up to their own website and make more money, so now we need account for everything. But imagine you didn’t, you could access different contents in the UI/format you want. You don’t need to share screenshots of different social media (shows why it’s useful), you could just follow different people from different websites.So far this explanation has worked. I haven’t converted anyone, but they understand. Sometimes they try to install and see, then say “the things I want are not here” because we don’t have all the niche
I’ve converted no one. But I get the most tempted looks when I say: there are no ads, and when you search for anime, noone is adding that to their secret database of your likes
Especially when you try to expliain that you can send stuff from mastodon to lemmy, but not lemmy to mastodon, unless it’s just tagging a user, and then it’s only on certain platforms.
We all play together, but we don’t all play the same way and it’s not always nice.
Will this reply show up in Mastodon??
Ah, wow. It does!
Forgive my ignorance but what is a Mastodon? I only ever heard it to be used as a animal
It’s a federated Twitter alternative. It’s existed for a while - the initial release was in 2016, but obviously with all the Musk-related nonsense in the past few years, it’s grown a lot.
It’s a federated service like Lemmy, but built to be a Twitter clone instead of reddit.
I would be so hyped to see a true dual Lemmy mastodon service that fully allows you to browse and post to both Lemmy and mastodon style feeds. Currently even kbin is really more focused on the Lemmy / piefed end and the microblogging function still requires the posts to be under a magazine meaning masto posts aren’t really browseable and they’re not really fully interact able from both ends. I feel like a service fully compatible with both formats would give a broader reach that would really allow fedi to grow. You’d be able interact with like half of fedi at the same time which would make it feel so much bigger and more comparable in scope to traditional social media.
I know mastodon posts/replies in lemmy when I see it starts the post by mentioning the community or author of the post haha.
I just wish the tags used on Mastodon didn’t end up in the body text when they end up on Lemmy. It can add a helluva lot of clutter when they add a thousand of those fuckers.
I would also like it if their posts didn’t start with tagging everyone in the thread.
It always looks funny tho. :D
Can you post new threads from Mastodon, or only comment to existing threads?
Both! If you notice this thread was made by a Mastodon account.
YSK that the first line will be the title of your post. It looks better on Lemmy/PieFed if you mention the community in the second line or further down.
Yes, the title looks fine here.
You should give an explanation on how to do it
@dnub On Mastodon simply tag the community like it’s a user. For example (at)youshouldknow(at)lemmy.world.
On Lemmy you can’t post to Mastodon really but you can mention a Mastodon user and they will get a notification. You can also message them.
Edit: Like I said some weirdness. This reply shows up on Piefed but not Lemmy.
Does this mean lemmy users can’t have the same name as communities? I’d just never noticed.
Actually in Lemmy you can. And yes it can cause issues. Some software handles this but it apparently (used to? Still does?) causes issues with Mastodon.
It does show up on lemmy, but sometimes it takes a while afaik.
deleted by creator
Yeah, that’s the wonder of the Fediverse. One network that can be interacted with by many tools and platforms.
Guess I’m on Mastodon now…
Look, you’re famous!
The beauty of interoperability. Thank you ActivityPub.
Kinda sorta.
The specific mastadon instance I’m on (mefi.social) does show the existence of lemmy communities and users, but it doesn’t import their posts or replies. mastodon.social seems and some other larger implementations seem to work fine though. I’m not sure if this is a configuration issue or what.
Information only gets sent to an instance if someone is following whatever created it.
If you follow a community as if it’s a user the posts will federate to your instance.
I did try that (following the community), but the mastodon account’s “request to follow” has been stuck in “awaiting approval” status. I run the Lemmy community that I’m trying to follow with my Mastodon account, but I don’t see how or where to approve these follow requests.
Are those requests gated by the mastodon admin perhaps?
I’m having the same problem. There was a bug for this (which was closed) https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/4341
It may have been re-opened, but I haven’t been able to find it after a quick search.
Sometimes Lemmy doesn’t send a response saying that the follow worked
If the mastodon instance never receives acknowledgement that the follow-request was approved, it’s probably not going to start fetching those messages. I’ve tried un-following and re-following; it still doesn’t work.
As I said intially, I think that qualifies the integration as only kinda-sorta working.
This didn’t work for me. Did I do something wrong?
Try following the communities first.
Not sure if it works for more than one community at a time, but maybe it does?
IIRC you must be following the community with your Mastodon Account to be able to post there. At least that was the problem, when I tried it the last time.
I tried again, this time after making sure to follow the community, but it still failed.
